This Is She or This Is Her: Which Is Correct? Grammar Rules and Examples

Imagine your phone rings. You answer, and the caller asks, “May I speak with Sarah?” You know they’re asking for you, but suddenly, a tiny grammar question pops into your head. Should you say “This is she” or “This is her”?

Both expressions appear in English conversations, yet they don’t always sound equally natural. One follows a traditional grammar rule. The other reflects patterns people commonly use in everyday speech.

Here’s the interesting part: English grammar isn’t always as simple as choosing the subject form or object form of a pronoun. Sometimes, the sentence structure, situation, and level of formality all influence your choice.

If you’ve ever wondered which phrase sounds correct on the phone, in a professional setting, or while identifying someone in a photograph, you’re in the right place.

This guide explains the difference with straightforward grammar rules, realistic conversations, helpful comparisons, and simple examples you can remember.

Table of Contents

This Is She or This Is Her: Quick Answer

“This is she” is traditionally correct in formal English when a woman identifies herself, especially on the phone. “This is her” is also possible in conversational English, particularly when identifying another woman.

However, the expressions aren’t always interchangeable.

Consider these examples:

Formal phone conversation:

“May I speak with Jennifer?”

“This is she.”

Casual conversation while looking at a photograph:

“Which woman is your sister?”

“This is her.”

Both examples communicate identification, but their contexts differ.

Here’s a quick comparison:

ExpressionTypical UseToneExample
This is sheIdentifying yourself, especially on the phoneFormal or traditional“Yes, this is she.”
This is herIdentifying a woman in conversationCasual or neutral“This is her in the picture.”
This is SarahIdentifying yourself or introducing SarahClear and neutral“Hello, this is Sarah.”
SpeakingResponding when someone asks for youProfessional or neutral“Sarah?” “Speaking.”
That’s meConfirming your identityCasual“Are you Sarah?” “That’s me.”

The easiest rule: Use “This is she” for traditional formal self-identification. Use “This is her” naturally when pointing out another woman. When you want to avoid uncertainty, use the person’s name.

Read this also: Fewer vs Less: Differences, Rules, and Examples

What’s the Difference Between “This Is She” and “This Is Her”?

The difference begins with two pronouns: she and her.

Both refer to a female person, but they usually perform different grammatical jobs.

“She” normally functions as a subject pronoun. “Her” can function as an object pronoun or a possessive determiner.

However, linking verbs such as is introduce an interesting exception to the simple rules students often learn.

What Does “This Is She” Mean?

“This is she” means that the woman speaking is the person someone wants to contact or identify.

You’ll most often encounter it in traditional telephone etiquette.

For example:

Caller: “Hello, is Mrs. Anderson available?”

Mrs. Anderson: “This is she.”

Mrs. Anderson confirms that she’s the person the caller wants.

The phrase sounds polite, slightly formal, and familiar to people who learned traditional telephone expressions.

You might also hear:

  • “Yes, this is she.”
  • “This is she speaking.”
  • “Hello, this is she.”

Although these expressions remain understandable, many speakers prefer simply saying their name.

What Does “This Is Her” Mean?

“This is her” often identifies a woman in a photograph, video, or conversation.

Imagine you’re showing your friend a family album.

Friend: “Which one is your aunt?”

You: “This is her.”

You’re pointing to the woman your friend asked about.

In conversational English, object-form pronouns frequently appear after forms of be, even though traditional grammar once favored subject forms in such positions.

That’s why expressions such as “It’s me,” “That’s him,” and “This is her” sound familiar.

However, when identifying yourself on the phone, “This is her” may sound less conventional than “This is she” or “This is Sarah.”

The Main Difference at a Glance

FeatureThis Is SheThis Is Her
PronounSheHer
Pronoun formSubject/nominativeObject/accusative
Traditional grammarPreferred after linking beTraditionally discouraged in the same construction
Modern conversational grammarAcceptableAcceptable in appropriate contexts
Phone self-identificationEstablished expressionLess conventional
Identifying another womanUsually unnaturalNatural
FormalityMore formalMore conversational

The real distinction involves both grammar and usage.

A sentence can follow a traditional rule yet sound unusual in everyday conversation.

Likewise, an expression can be natural and widely accepted without following every older prescriptive convention.

Why Is “This Is She” Traditionally Considered Correct?

Traditional grammar treats the verb be differently from ordinary action verbs.

To understand why, you need to know how linking verbs work.

Understanding Linking Verbs and Subject Complements

A linking verb connects the subject of a sentence with information that identifies or describes it.

Common linking verbs include:

  • Am
  • Is
  • Are
  • Was
  • Were
  • Seem
  • Become

Consider this sentence:

“Sarah is the manager.”

“Sarah” is the subject. “Is” links Sarah with “the manager,” which identifies her role.

Now consider:

“This is she.”

“This” is the grammatical subject. “Is” connects it with “she.”

Traditional grammar calls the pronoun after the linking verb a subject complement, more specifically a predicate nominative when it identifies the subject.

Under the traditional rule, this complement takes the subject form.

That’s why older grammar instruction favors “This is she.”

Why Traditional Grammar Uses “She” After “Is”

Traditional formal grammar favors nominative pronouns when a pronoun identifies the subject after a linking verb.

Compare these examples:

Traditional Formal FormEveryday Conversational Form
It is I.It’s me.
It was he.It was him.
This is she.This is her.
It was they.It was them.

The left column reflects the traditional prescription. The right column illustrates patterns found in modern conversational English.

Importantly, these aren’t all equally natural in every context.

For example, “This is she” remains an established telephone response, while “It is I” often sounds theatrical or deliberately formal.

English usage depends on more than a single mechanical rule.

Examples of “This Is She” in Formal English

Example: A medical office calls a patient

Receptionist: “May I speak with Mrs. Wilson?”

Mrs. Wilson: “This is she.”

Example: A company contacts a job applicant

Recruiter: “Hello, am I speaking with Emily Carter?”

Emily: “Yes, this is she.”

Example: A school calls a parent

School secretary: “Could I speak with Mrs. Thompson?”

Mrs. Thompson: “This is she. How can I help?”

These examples show why the expression remains useful.

It’s short, polite, and immediately confirms the speaker’s identity.

Why Does “This Is Her” Sound Natural in Everyday English?

English speakers don’t always use the nominative pronoun after be.

In fact, conversational English often favors object-form pronouns in short identifying expressions.

Think about the last time someone asked, “Who’s there?”

You probably wouldn’t respond, “It is I.”

You’d say, “It’s me.”

That familiar pattern helps explain why “This is her” can sound natural.

How Modern English Uses Object-Form Pronouns

English uses object-form pronouns in several conversational constructions beyond direct objects.

Consider:

“Who’s responsible?”

“Him.”

“Who’s at the door?”

“It’s me.”

“Which person is your cousin?”

“That’s her.”

These responses are normal in everyday speech.

Although traditional grammar distinguishes nominative and objective cases, modern usage allows object-form pronouns in many positions where older rules preferred nominative forms.

Is “This Is Her” Grammatically Incorrect?

Not necessarily.

In modern conversational English, “This is her” can be grammatically acceptable.

However, the situation matters.

Suppose you’re identifying a woman in a picture.

“This is her.”

That sounds natural.

Now imagine someone calls your office and asks for you.

Caller: “May I speak with Rebecca?”

You: “This is her.”

Some speakers use this response, but others find it awkward or nonstandard for telephone self-identification.

“This is she,” “Speaking,” or “This is Rebecca” may be better choices.

The distinction isn’t simply correct versus incorrect. It’s about conventional usage and audience expectations.

When “This Is Her” Is the Better Choice

“This is her” works particularly well when identifying someone else.

For example:

“Which woman helped you yesterday?”

“This is her.”

Or:

“Is that the woman you were talking about?”

“Yes, that’s her.”

These examples use the object-form pronoun naturally.

Notice that “That’s her” is especially common when confirming another person’s identity.

“This Is She” or “This Is Her” When Answering the Phone?

Phone conversations create one of the most common situations where this grammar question appears.

The caller asks for someone by name. The person answering must confirm their identity.

Several responses work, but they create slightly different impressions.

The Traditional Formal Response: “This Is She”

Caller: “Good morning. May I speak with Dr. Parker?”

Dr. Parker: “This is she.”

This response follows traditional telephone etiquette.

It sounds polite and somewhat formal.

The Conversational Response: “This Is Her”

Caller: “Is Amanda there?”

Amanda: “This is her.”

This response occurs in casual speech, although it isn’t the conventional formal choice.

Some listeners may find it completely natural. Others may prefer “This is she.”

If you’re uncertain about your audience, choose a more neutral expression.

The Clear Alternative: “This Is Sarah”

Caller: “Hello, may I speak with Sarah?”

Sarah: “Hi, this is Sarah.”

This is one of the clearest options.

It avoids the pronoun debate and works in both personal and professional conversations.

Other Natural Responses: “Speaking” and “Yes, That’s Me”

You don’t always need a complete sentence.

Caller: “Could I speak with Jennifer?”

Jennifer: “Speaking.”

Or:

Caller: “Are you Jennifer?”

Jennifer: “Yes, that’s me.”

Both responses sound natural.

“Speaking” is especially useful during business calls, while “That’s me” works comfortably in informal conversations.

When Should You Use “This Is She”?

The expression is most useful when you want to sound traditional, polite, or formally correct.

Formal Phone Conversations

When someone calls and asks for you, “This is she” is an established response.

For example:

“May I speak with Ms. Brown?”

“Yes, this is she.”

It immediately confirms your identity.

Professional Self-Identification

You can use the expression during professional calls, particularly when you prefer formal language.

However, it isn’t required for professionalism.

“Hello, this is Laura Brown” sounds equally professional and may communicate your identity more clearly.

Formal Grammar Exercises and Exams

Traditional grammar exercises may expect “she” after a linking verb.

For example:

Choose the traditionally correct response:

“May I speak with Mary?”

A. This is her.

B. This is she.

Under the traditional rule, B. This is she is the expected answer.

However, a modern descriptive grammar question may recognize conversational alternatives.

Always consider the grammatical standard your exam tests.

When Should You Use “This Is Her”?

“This is her” is especially useful when identifying a woman rather than identifying yourself.

Identifying Someone in a Picture

Imagine your friend asks:

“Which person is your teacher?”

You point to a photograph and say:

“This is her.”

The sentence identifies the woman being discussed.

Pointing Out a Person in Conversation

Suppose you’re watching a video.

Friend: “Which woman won the competition?”

You: “This is her.”

This sounds natural when you’re pointing to the person.

You could also say, “That’s her,” which may be even more conversational.

Casual Introductions and Everyday Speech

When introducing someone, a name usually sounds clearer than a standalone pronoun.

For example:

“This is my friend Olivia.”

Or:

“This is Olivia. She’s my coworker.”

Although “This is her” can identify a previously mentioned woman, it isn’t usually the best way to introduce someone new.

One important distinction involves possessive grammar.

Compare:

“This is her.”

Here, “her” is a pronoun.

“This is her sister.”

Here, “her” is a possessive determiner describing whose sister you’re identifying.

The word looks identical, but its grammatical job changes.

The Grammar Behind “She” and “Her” Explained Simply

Understanding these two pronouns makes many English sentences easier.

The key is recognizing what each word does.

When to Use “She” as a Subject Pronoun

Use she when the woman performs an action or serves as the subject of a clause.

Examples:

  • She works at the hospital.
  • She enjoys reading.
  • She called me yesterday.
  • She teaches English.
  • She has already left.

In each sentence, “she” is the subject.

Consider:

“She helped me.”

Who helped? She did.

The pronoun identifies the person performing the action.

When to Use “Her” as an Object Pronoun

Use her when the woman receives an action or follows a preposition.

Examples:

  • I called her.
  • We invited her.
  • Sarah helped her.
  • I spoke to her.
  • They bought a gift for her.

Consider:

“John called her.”

John performs the action. The woman receives it.

Therefore, “her” functions as the object.

When “Her” Works as a Possessive Determiner

The word “her” can also show possession.

Examples:

  • Her phone is ringing.
  • This is her car.
  • I met her brother.
  • Her teacher called yesterday.

Notice that a noun follows “her” in each example.

In “This is her car,” the word “her” describes whose car it is.

In “This is her,” the word “her” stands alone as a pronoun.

That’s an important grammatical distinction.

Why Pronouns After “Be” Follow Different Patterns

Here’s where English becomes interesting.

Normally, learners remember that subjects take “she” and objects take “her.”

But a pronoun following is isn’t necessarily an object.

The verb be connects the subject with a complement rather than transferring an action to an object.

Traditional grammar favors subject-form pronouns in these complements.

Modern conversational grammar also accepts object-form pronouns in many such constructions. Cambridge’s English Grammar Today explicitly recognizes examples like “That’s him” and “It’s me.” Cambridge Grammar+1

The useful rule is:

Use “she” as an ordinary subject and “her” as an ordinary object. After a linking verb, consider the expression and the level of formality.

Real-Life Examples of “This Is She” and “This Is Her”

Grammar rules become easier when you see them in everyday situations.

These illustrative conversations show how context influences the expression.

Answering a Business Phone Call

Receptionist: “Good afternoon. May I speak with Ms. Davis?”

Ms. Davis: “This is she. How may I help you?”

Explanation: Ms. Davis uses a traditional formal response to identify herself.

Answering a Personal Phone Call

Caller: “Hey, is Rachel there?”

Rachel: “Yeah, that’s me.”

Explanation: Rachel chooses a casual response that sounds natural between friends.

Identifying a Woman in a Photograph

Emma: “Which woman is your grandmother?”

Olivia: “This is her, standing beside my grandfather.”

Explanation: Olivia identifies another woman. “Her” works naturally in this context.

Introducing Someone at a Gathering

Host: “Everyone, this is my friend Sophia.”

Sophia: “Nice to meet you!”

Explanation: Using the person’s name is clearer than saying “This is her” when making an introduction.

Responding to Someone Asking for Sarah

Caller: “Hello, is Sarah available?”

Sarah: “Speaking.”

Explanation: Sarah confirms her identity without using either disputed expression.

Pointing Out a Person in a Video

Daniel: “Is that the actress you mentioned?”

Mia: “Yes, that’s her.”

Explanation: “That’s her” is a natural conversational expression for identifying someone.

These examples reveal an important pattern: the most suitable expression depends on what you’re doing, not just the pronoun itself.

American English vs. British English

Both American and British English distinguish subject pronouns from object pronouns.

Speakers in both varieties also use object-form pronouns after be in everyday conversation.

However, telephone expressions and levels of formality can vary among individuals.

Usage in American English

In American English, “This is she” is an established formal telephone response.

For example:

“May I speak with Karen?”

“This is she.”

You’ll also hear alternatives such as:

  • “This is Karen.”
  • “Speaking.”
  • “Yes, that’s me.”

American speakers commonly use expressions like “It’s me” and “That’s her” in everyday conversation.

Usage in British English

British English also accepts object-form pronouns in conversational complements.

For example:

“Who’s at the door?”

“It’s me.”

Or:

“Is that your sister?”

“Yes, that’s her.”

“This is she” is understandable in British English, although it may sound particularly formal or less familiar to some speakers.

Why Context Matters More Than Nationality

It’s misleading to claim that all Americans prefer one form while all British speakers prefer another.

Individual preferences depend on age, education, region, social setting, and personal speaking style.

A formal American speaker may choose “This is she.”

A casual American speaker may prefer “This is Sarah.”

The same variation exists in British English.

Instead of memorizing a rigid national difference, focus on what sounds appropriate in the conversation.

Also see this: Loose vs Lose: Meaning, Differences, Examples, and Easy Ways to Remember

Is “This Is She” Old-Fashioned or Still Correct?

“This is she” is still grammatically valid.

However, it can sound formal or traditional compared with modern conversational alternatives.

Imagine someone knocking on your door.

Person outside: “Who’s there?”

You: “It is I!”

That response might sound like dialogue from a historical drama.

Most people would simply say:

“It’s me!”

The same contrast helps explain why “This is she” sometimes sounds old-fashioned.

Still, the expression hasn’t disappeared from telephone etiquette.

People who prefer formal speech may use it comfortably.

The important point is that old-fashioned doesn’t mean incorrect.

A traditional expression can remain correct even when newer alternatives become more familiar.

“It Is I” vs. “It Is Me”: A Helpful Grammar Comparison

One of the easiest ways to understand this debate is to compare two familiar expressions.

“It is I.”

“It’s me.”

Both identify the speaker.

However, they represent different grammatical traditions.

Why “It Is I” Follows Traditional Grammar

Under the traditional predicate nominative rule, the pronoun following is takes the nominative form.

Therefore:

“It is I.”

The pronoun “I” identifies the subject “it.”

Traditional grammar books favor this structure.

Why “It’s Me” Is Natural in Modern English

In everyday speech, people overwhelmingly recognize “It’s me” as an ordinary, natural expression.

Imagine calling your friend.

Friend: “Who’s calling?”

You: “It’s me.”

The response is clear and familiar.

Saying “It is I” would sound unusually formal in most casual conversations.

How This Comparison Explains the Difference

The same pattern applies to:

Traditional FormConversational Form
It is I.It’s me.
It was he.It was him.
That is she.That’s her.
It was they.It was them.

However, established phrases have their own conventions.

For instance, “This is she” remains a recognizable telephone response even though “It’s me” is much more natural than “It is I.”

That’s why grammar rules and real-life usage should be considered together.

See this also: Accept vs Except: Difference, Meaning, and Examples

Common Mistakes With “She” and “Her”

Several mistakes occur when learners apply one grammar rule to every sentence.

Let’s clear up the most important ones.

Thinking “This Is Her” Is Always Wrong

Mistaken belief: “Her” can never follow “is.”

Better understanding: Object-form pronouns commonly follow be in conversational English.

For example:

“That’s her in the blue dress.”

This sentence is natural.

Using “Her” as the Subject of an Ordinary Sentence

Incorrect: Her works at the hospital.

Correct: She works at the hospital.

Here, the pronoun is the subject of “works,” so “she” is required in standard English.

Using “She” as a Direct Object

Incorrect: I invited she.

Correct: I invited her.

The pronoun receives the action of “invited.”

Therefore, use “her.”

Confusing “This Is Her” With “This Is Her Book”

These sentences contain different grammatical structures.

“This is her.”

“Her” is a personal pronoun.

“This is her book.”

“Her” is a possessive determiner modifying “book.”

Don’t assume the word has the same function simply because its spelling stays unchanged.

Assuming Formal Grammar Is Always the Most Natural Choice

Very formal: “It is I.”

Natural: “It’s me.”

The formal expression follows a traditional rule, but the conversational expression is generally more suitable for everyday speech.

Using “This Is She” When Referring to Someone Else

Imagine you’re pointing at your sister in a photograph.

Saying “This is she” would sound unnatural in ordinary conversation.

Instead, say:

“This is my sister.”

Or:

“This is her.”

When referring to someone else, the conversational form is usually more appropriate.

Easy Memory Tricks for Choosing “She” or “Her”

You don’t need to memorize complicated terminology to use these pronouns correctly.

A few practical rules will help.

Use “She” Before an Ordinary Verb

When the woman performs an action, choose “she.”

Examples:

  • She sings beautifully.
  • She drives carefully.
  • She understands the lesson.

Memory trick: If you can replace the pronoun with a woman’s name as the subject, “she” probably fits.

Use “Her” After an Action Verb or Preposition

When the woman receives an action, choose “her.”

Examples:

  • I saw her.
  • We helped her.
  • He spoke to her.

This rule works for ordinary objects.

Remember the Special Case After “Is”

After is, the choice isn’t always determined by the simple subject/object rule.

Traditional formal grammar may favor “she.”

Modern conversational English may use “her.”

Consider the situation before choosing.

Use a Name When You Want to Avoid Confusion

This is particularly helpful during telephone conversations.

Instead of worrying about which pronoun sounds best, say:

“Hello, this is Jessica.”

It’s simple, natural, and professional.

Quick Practice: Choose “She” or “Her”

Test your understanding with these multiple-choice questions.

Grammar Practice

1. _____ works at the hospital.A. SheB. HerC. HersD. Herself

2. I spoke to _____ yesterday.A. sheB. hersC. herD. herself

3. May I speak with Mrs. Wilson? Yes, this is _____. (Traditional formal response)A. herB. sheC. hersD. herself

4. Look at this picture. That’s _____ beside the window.A. sheB. hersC. herD. herself

5. _____ called me this morning.A. HerB. HersC. SheD. Herself

6. This is _____ notebook.A. sheB. hersC. herD. herself

7. The teacher praised _____ for her excellent work.A. sheB. herC. hersD. herself

8. Who is that woman? That’s _____.A. herB. sheC. hersD. herself

Read this also: Alligator vs Crocodile: 10 Key Differences, Size, Teeth, Habitat & More

Frequently Asked Questions

Is “This Is She” Grammatically Correct?

Yes. “This is she” follows the traditional rule for nominative pronouns after linking verbs. It’s especially familiar as a formal telephone response when a woman identifies herself.

Is “This Is Her” Grammatically Correct?

Yes, in appropriate conversational contexts. “This is her” can naturally identify a woman in a photograph or conversation. Some speakers also use it for telephone self-identification, although “This is she” is the traditional choice.

Should I Say “This Is She” When Answering the Phone?

You can. It’s a polite, established response. However, “This is [your name]” or “Speaking” may sound more natural while remaining professional.

Can I Say “This Is Her” When Someone Calls Me?

Yes, some speakers use it conversationally. However, it may sound less conventional to people who expect traditional telephone etiquette. Using your name is a reliable alternative.

Why Do People Say “This Is She” of “This Is Her”?

Traditional grammar favors the nominative pronoun after a linking verb. This convention became part of formal telephone etiquette, which explains why “This is she” remains familiar.

Which Expression Sounds More ?

“This is she” sounds more traditional and formal. However, “This is [your name]” is equally professional and often clearer. Professionalism depends more on your overall communication than on this single expression.

Is “This Is She” Old-Fashioned?

It can sound old-fashioned to some listeners, but it remains grammatically valid. The expression survives particularly in formal telephone conversations.

Is “This Is Her” Correct in American English?

Yes. American English accepts object-form pronouns after be in many conversational contexts. “This is her” is natural when identifying another woman, although telephone self-identification follows additional conventions.

What’s the Difference Between “She” and “Her”?

“She” is normally a subject pronoun, as in “She called me.” “Her” is an object pronoun or possessive determiner, as in “I called her” and “Her phone rang.”

Which Expression Should I Use in a Grammar Exam?

If the question tests the traditional predicate nominative rule, “This is she” is usually the expected answer. For questions about natural conversational usage, context may support “This is her.”

Final Verdict: Which Phrase Should You Choose?

The This Is She or This Is Her question doesn’t have a single answer that fits every situation.

Both expressions have legitimate uses, but their tone and context differ.

Choose “This is she” when you want a traditional formal response while identifying yourself on the phone.

Choose “This is her” when you’re naturally identifying another woman in conversation or a photograph.

Choose “This is [name]” when you want a clear expression that works almost anywhere.

The most important lesson is that traditional grammar and everyday usage aren’t always identical. Understanding both helps you speak confidently without making your sentences unnecessarily formal.

After all, good grammar isn’t just about following rules. It’s also about choosing words that communicate your meaning clearly.

Leave a Comment